Talk to us 
Wealth Planning
How to Effectively Manage Capital Gains from Concentrated Stock Positions
Selling the business was the easy part. What came next was more complex, especially as the family began navigating shared wealth, decision-making and new roles across generations.
Two brothers, who had been working in the family business since they were old enough to hold a broom, found themselves rudderless without the company to organize their daily lives, decisions and sense of purpose and self. The two sisters, both retired teachers, had been perfectly happy to leave all the business decision-making to their brothers.
Post-sale, the sisters wanted an equal say in how to allocate the shared liquid assets, but the brothers were used to making decisions alone and did not believe their sisters had the financial acumen to provide input. The brothers went ahead and invested the money. Nobody was happy. Trust eroded. Everybody stopped talking to each other and relationships became strained.
Why do financial conversations often become more complex after a liquidity event or generational transition?
Situations like this are more common than many families expect, particularly when transitioning from an operating business to shared wealth. In our work with multigenerational families, including those we support through our Aspiriant Exclusive Family Office, we often see how differences in experience, expectations and unspoken assumptions shape financial conversations.
In these moments, families are often supported by a multidisciplinary team that may include investment, planning, legal and philanthropic advisors. In some cases, that team also includes a historian, whose role is to help bring context to the family’s story and decisions.
Before returning to how this unfolded for the family, it helps to step back and explore how families make meaning of their experiences.
Why financial conversations can feel more complex than expected
In conversations with multigenerational families, we have seen how these situations unfold. An agenda that appears clear on paper, thoughtful intentions on every side and yet a discussion that slowly circles the same questions.
A pause lingers longer than expected. Words are chosen carefully. Someone offers a perspective and someone else retreats into silence. No one is trying to create tension, and still, something feels unsettled.
It might be a discussion about the family business succession plan. Or how to prepare the rising generation family members for leadership roles. Or how to align multi-generational shared values with philanthropy. On the surface, these topics are practical. Beneath them, they are often deeply personal.
When conversations feel heavier than expected, it is rarely because planning is inadequate. More often, each person is carrying different experiences. Different assumptions. Different stories about what this wealth means and what it requires.
This perspective reflects years of working alongside families and the professionals who support them. Together, we have seen how context can change conversations.
What families often need in these moments is not more structure, but shared understanding.
When clarity can be harder to achieve in family wealth conversations
In our work with families, we often see that moments of tension do not arise because people lack good intentions. They arise because family members are holding different histories, interpretations and emotional experiences around money.
When those perspectives remain unspoken, even well-designed plans can feel harder to carry out. Creating space to understand where the perspectives come from can shift the tone of a conversation entirely.
As families grow more complex, financially and relationally, this gap becomes more noticeable. The questions shift from “What should we do?” to “How do we talk about this?” and “Why does this feel harder than it needs to?”
For families operating within a family office or multifamily office structure, these conversations often intersect with governance decisions, succession planning and long-term stewardship. In our work with clients in our Exclusive Family Office, we see how these themes show up not just in planning, but in how families communicate, make decisions and move forward together.
Why family stories shape financial decisions more than we expect
Stories are one of the primary ways people communicate and make meaning. Consciously or not, stories shape identity, values and expectations.
In families navigating multigenerational wealth planning, stories often influence how decisions are made. They affect how responsibility is viewed, how risk is tolerated, how conflict is handled and how younger generations see their place in the family.
When stories go unspoken or unexamined, gaps and assumptions can form. Children may sense that certain topics are charged without understanding the “why” behind a decision or a process. Parents may assume values have been transmitted when they have not. Over time, misunderstandings can harden into patterns that feel difficult to change.
Exploring family history can offer a way to surface greater context for the family. Not to dwell on the past, but to give the family a clearer sense of direction to navigate challenges they have often felt but could not quite name.
Family history as a bridge, not a spotlight
Used thoughtfully, family history is not about celebrating ancestors or creating a polished legacy narrative. It is not a museum exhibit or a branding exercise. It is about building a bridge within and between generations.
A bridge allows people to move toward one another. It creates connection where there might otherwise be distance. It makes it possible to cross from assumption to understanding.
At its best, revisiting family history creates space for families to see how past choices, sacrifices and turning points faced by their ancestors shaped the opportunities they hold today. Conversations begin from shared perspective rather than from defensiveness.
In practice, that bridge can take many forms. It might begin with a simple question posed at a family gathering, often starting with everyday experiences before moving into conversations about money.
What food, song or smell makes you remember a happy family time?
What’s a meaningful lesson you’ve learned from a family member?
If you could have a conversation with anybody on the family tree, who would it be? What would you want to ask?
Questions like these invite reflection without accusation. They allow stories to surface organically, often revealing values and assumptions that had never been spoken aloud.
In more formal settings, families may choose to engage in facilitated conversations that include reflection, discussion and bringing what emerges into future decisions. The structure matters. It ensures every voice is heard before conclusions are drawn.
When used intentionally, family history may help families:
- Open conversations about responsibility without sounding prescriptive
- Prepare rising generations by connecting them to their family’s journey
- Discuss governance, roles or succession without making conversations personal
- Clarify where certain values originated
- Draw perspective from how earlier generations navigated uncertainty
- Strengthen connection across branches of a family
History can be especially helpful for some families, particularly during periods of transition, whether that involves leadership succession, the sale of a family enterprise or generational change following loss.
|
“When families understand the context behind their shared history, conversations often begin to shift. There’s typically more patience, greater curiosity and a stronger sense of collaboration.” |
Lisa Colletti CFP®, JD |
How these dynamics show up in real family conversations
For this family, navigating life after the sale of their business, the path forward required more than technical expertise alone.
A multidisciplinary team worked with all four siblings, both individually and together, to help move the family forward. This included a historian alongside investment, planning and other advisors.
The brothers focused on an oral history of the business. They wanted future generations to understand how the family fortune had been created and their leadership roles in that story. The sisters focused on family history to understand the non-financial legacy and how to honor it.
Family meetings provided a space to share stories and explore their significance. The history work provided a deep foundation upon which the family could both respect individual strengths and perspectives and also build a future together that aligned shared identity and values with financial decisions.
Situations like this often show up in different ways across families:
- A sense that rising generations do not fully understand the “why” behind the wealth
- Uncertainty about when and how to introduce responsibility
- Frustration that family meetings feel tense or unproductive
- A desire to align around purpose without forcing agreement
These moments rarely feel dramatic. They feel slow. Circular. Slightly unresolved.
A shared story can offer a different entry point. Instead of beginning with a decision, families begin with perspective. Instead of debating outcomes, they explore context. Even small gestures matter. A meaningful detail remembered. A story recalled at the right time. A question that invites reflection rather than debate. These moments signal care. They build trust gradually.
Over time, this can create common ground where conversation once felt strained. These conversations can then begin to support clearer communication and more thoughtful coordination, especially as families’ needs become more complex and multigenerational.
|
Example: A shift in perspective
A matriarch worried that her grandchildren lacked a sense of purpose and responsibility. She was particularly concerned about one grandson, who spent more time at the gym than at school and whose father had struggled with addiction for much of his life.
At a family retreat, each of the 23 family members was invited to bring an object or image that represented something meaningful to them and share the story behind it.
The grandson was the only member of his generation who chose to participate. His object was tied to a vacation with the entire extended family, and he spoke about what that experience meant to him in front of everyone.
In a single moment, the grandmother’s perspective began to shift. What she had seen as disengagement revealed something different: care, thoughtfulness, vulnerability, participation and personal growth. Moments like this can create a new starting point for conversation.
|
How family history can support future decisions
Families do not need a perfect family history narrative to move forward. They do not need consensus on every memory or interpretation.
But it can be powerful to pause and ask:
- What stories are shaping our decisions today, even if we have not named them?
- What do our children understand about how this wealth came to be?
- What assumptions are we carrying that have never been spoken aloud?
- What shared understanding would make our next conversation easier?
Thoughtful planning extends beyond financial outcomes. It includes helping families navigate conversations with clarity, empathy and shared understanding.
When families take time to reflect on the stories that shaped them, conversations often feel more open and grounded, creating a stronger foundation for what comes next.
Explore how we support multigenerational families
For families navigating increasing complexity across generations, thoughtful coordination matters. Explore how our Exclusive Family Office is designed to support multigenerational wealth planning.
If these themes resonate with your family’s experience, we welcome the opportunity to continue the conversation.
